Dallo Insurance Group Reviews From Michigan Clients

How Life Insurance Funds a Buy-Sell Agreement, and What the Connelly Ruling Changed

 

A buy-sell agreement is a contract among business owners that decides what happens to an owner's share of the company if that owner dies, becomes disabled, retires, or leaves. Life insurance is the most common way to fund the death buyout. Each owner, or the business itself, holds a policy on the other owners, so when an owner passes away, the death benefit provides the cash to buy that owner's share from the family at the price the agreement sets.

 

Without that funding, a buy-sell agreement is a promise with no money behind it. The surviving owners may have to borrow, drain the company's cash, or sell assets to complete the buyout. The deceased owner's family may wait years to be paid, or end up as partners in a business they never planned to run. For the closely held and family-owned businesses we work with across Shelby Township, Troy, Bloomfield Hills, Birmingham, and the rest of Metro Detroit, a funded buy-sell agreement is one of the most important steps in protecting both the company and the people who built it.

 

This guide from Dallo Insurance Group explains how life insurance funds a buy-sell agreement, the two main structures, how a 2024 Supreme Court decision changed the planning, and how to decide how much coverage you need.

 

What Happens to a Business When an Owner Dies Without a Funded Plan

 

When an owner of a partnership, LLC, or closely held corporation dies, that owner's interest usually passes to their estate and heirs. That creates a set of problems that arrive all at once.

 

The surviving owners may suddenly share decisions with a spouse or adult children who have no experience in the business. The family, meanwhile, often needs cash for living expenses and estate costs more than it needs a share of a company that may not pay regular distributions. Disagreements over what the share is worth can turn into long negotiations or litigation. Customers, lenders, and employees may lose confidence while ownership is uncertain.

 

A buy-sell agreement addresses those problems ahead of time by setting who can buy the interest, who must sell it, what triggers the sale, and how the price is determined. Life insurance addresses the remaining question: where the money comes from.

 

How Life Insurance Funds the Buyout

 

The mechanics are simple. Policies are purchased on each owner's life, with death benefits sized to match the value of each owner's share. When an owner dies, the death benefit is paid, generally income tax-free, to the policy's owner and beneficiary. That money is then used to purchase the deceased owner's interest from the estate under the terms of the agreement.

 

The family receives cash at a fair, agreed-upon price. The surviving owners receive full control of the business without taking on debt. The company keeps operating without draining its working capital.

 

Who owns and is the beneficiary of each policy depends on which structure the agreement uses. That choice has tax, valuation, and practical consequences, and it became more important after 2024.

 

Cross-Purchase vs. Entity Redemption Agreements

 

There are two main structures for a buy-sell agreement, and many agreements blend features of both.

 

In a cross-purchase agreement, the owners agree to buy each other's interests directly. Each owner buys and owns a life insurance policy on each of the other owners. When an owner dies, the surviving owners collect the death benefits and use them to buy the deceased owner's share. A practical benefit is that the surviving owners typically receive a higher cost basis in the interest they purchase, which can reduce capital gains if they later sell. The drawback is the number of policies. With two owners, you need two policies. With four owners, each owner insures the other three, which means twelve policies. Some businesses address that complexity with a trusteed arrangement or a separate entity that holds the policies, which is a question for your attorney.

 

In an entity redemption agreement, sometimes called a stock redemption agreement, the business itself agrees to buy back the deceased owner's interest. The company owns one policy on each owner and is the beneficiary. When an owner dies, the business collects the death benefit and redeems the shares. This structure is simpler to administer, since the number of policies equals the number of owners, and premiums are paid by the business. For years, it was the default choice for many closely held corporations.

 

What the Connelly Ruling Changed for Buy-Sell Planning

 

In June 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Connelly v. United States, a unanimous decision with significant consequences for entity redemption agreements funded with life insurance.

 

The case involved two brothers who owned a building supply corporation. The corporation owned life insurance on each brother to fund a redemption agreement. When one brother died, the company received about $3 million in insurance proceeds and used it to redeem his shares. His estate valued the company as if the insurance proceeds were offset by the obligation to buy back the shares. The IRS disagreed, and the Supreme Court sided with the IRS. The Court held that the life insurance proceeds were a corporate asset that increased the company's value for federal estate tax purposes, and that the obligation to redeem the shares did not automatically offset that asset.

 

In practical terms, under an entity redemption agreement, the life insurance the company receives can increase the value of the deceased owner's shares for estate tax purposes, potentially increasing estate tax for owners whose estates are large enough to owe it. The Court noted that other structures, including cross-purchase agreements, remain available to accomplish the same goals.

 

This doesn't mean entity redemption agreements are wrong for every business. Many owners' estates fall below the federal estate tax exemption, and the decision was narrow. But it does mean that every corporation with a life-insurance-funded redemption agreement should have its attorney and CPA review it, and that new agreements should weigh the structure carefully. Our agency works alongside your advisors to place or restructure the policies once the right structure is chosen.

 

How Much Life Insurance Does a Buy-Sell Agreement Need?

 

The death benefit should match each owner's share of the business value, as determined by the valuation method in your agreement. Common approaches include a fixed price the owners update regularly, a formula based on earnings or book value, or an independent appraisal at the time of death.

 

The most common funding mistake is letting coverage fall behind the business. A company worth $1 million when the agreement was signed may be worth $3 million a decade later. If the policies still pay $500,000 per owner, the surviving owners will have to come up with the difference. That's why we recommend reviewing the agreement's valuation and the life insurance amounts together every year or two, and whenever the business grows significantly, adds owners, or changes structure.

 

Ownership percentages matter as well. In a business owned 60 and 40, the policies should reflect each owner's actual share, and coverage should be adjusted if those percentages change.

 

Choosing the Right Type of Life Insurance

 

The policy type depends on how long the agreement needs to be funded and how the owners want to pay for it.

 

Permanent coverage, such as whole life or universal life insurance, is designed to last for the insured's lifetime. That matters for buy-sell agreements because the obligation lasts as long as the owners own the business, and many owners stay involved well into their sixties and seventies. Whole life offers level premiums and predictable cash value growth. Universal life offers more flexibility in premium payments and death benefit amounts, which can help a business whose cash flow varies from year to year. Cash value in a permanent policy may also help fund a lifetime buyout when an owner retires, depending on how the agreement is written.

 

Some owners use temporary coverage for part of the funding, particularly when the business is young or the owners expect a sale within a set period. The right mix depends on your ages, health, budget, and exit plans. As an independent agency, Dallo Insurance Group compares policies from multiple carriers, which matters when owners have different ages or health histories.

 

Steps to Put a Funded Buy-Sell Agreement in Place

 

The process usually starts with the owners agreeing on goals: who should be able to buy an interest, what events should trigger a sale, and how the price should be set. Your attorney drafts the agreement itself, and your CPA advises on tax treatment and valuation. Our agency helps select and place the life insurance, coordinates the policy ownership and beneficiary designations with the structure your attorney chooses, and helps you review coverage over time.

 

Underwriting typically involves a health questionnaire and sometimes a medical exam for each owner. Starting the process early, while owners are younger and healthier, generally means more options and lower premiums.

 

Buy-Sell Planning Beyond Michigan

 

Many of the business owners we work with have operations or partners outside Michigan. Dallo Insurance Group is licensed in Michigan, Arizona, Illinois, and Tennessee, so we can place life insurance for owners who live in any of those states and coordinate coverage for the whole ownership group through one agency.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Buy-Sell Agreement Life Insurance

 

How does life insurance fund a buy-sell agreement?

Policies are purchased on each owner's life. When an owner dies, the death benefit provides the cash for the surviving owners or the business to buy the deceased owner's share from the estate at the price set in the agreement.

 

What happens to my business if my partner dies without a buy-sell agreement?

Your partner's ownership interest typically passes to their estate and heirs. You may end up sharing control with their family, negotiating a price without a set method, or struggling to come up with the cash for a buyout.

 

What is the difference between cross-purchase and entity redemption?

In a cross-purchase agreement, the owners buy policies on each other and purchase the deceased owner's share directly. In an entity redemption agreement, the business owns the policies and buys back the share itself. Each has different tax, valuation, and administrative consequences.

 

How did Connelly v. United States affect buy-sell agreements?

In 2024, the Supreme Court ruled that life insurance proceeds a corporation receives to redeem a deceased owner's shares count as a corporate asset for federal estate tax valuation and aren't automatically offset by the redemption obligation. Corporations with entity redemption agreements should have them reviewed by their attorney and CPA.

 

How much life insurance do I need for a buy-sell agreement?

Enough to cover each owner's share of the business at its current value under your agreement's valuation method. Review the coverage every year or two, since business values often grow faster than the policies funding them.

 

Do I need an attorney to set up a buy-sell agreement?

Yes. The agreement is a legal contract and should be drafted by an attorney, with tax guidance from your CPA. Our agency helps you choose and place the life insurance that funds it.

 

Is there a life insurance agency for business owners near Troy or Shelby Township?

Yes. Dallo Insurance Group is headquartered in Shelby Township and works with business owners throughout Macomb, Oakland, and Wayne counties, as well as in Arizona, Illinois, and Tennessee. Call 248-606-4991.

 

Protect the Business You Built and the People Who Depend on It

 

A buy-sell agreement only works if the money is there when it's needed. Dallo Insurance Group helps business owners choose, place, and review the life insurance that funds their buy-sell agreements, working alongside their attorney and CPA, and reviews it with their commercial insurance so the whole business is protected. Call our agency at 248-606-4991 or request a quote online, and you'll typically hear back within about an hour.

 

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Consult your attorney and CPA about your buy-sell agreement's structure, valuation, and tax treatment.

See Why Clients Call Us Back for Every Policy

The best way to find out what our clients are talking about is to call. Tell us what you need, and our team will get back to you, usually the same day.